The Libreboot project, which develops free bootable firmware, announced a revision of the rules approved last month that prohibited any use of AI tools when developing changes. It is stated that the Libreboot developers remain opposed to the use of AI, but recognize the impossibility of fighting against the expansion of AI alone, in an environment where the projects on which Libreboot depends, such as the Linux kernel, CoreBoot and EDK2, allow changes generated through AI. It is recognized that without forking CoreBoot and EDK2 it is impossible to get rid of the appearance of AI code, but Libreboot does not have the resources to do such work.
In order to counter the expansion of AI, a mass refusal to accept AI-generated code and promotion of such a policy by large projects such as the Linux kernel is necessary, but this is not happening. Therefore, it was decided not to persist in trying to change the world alone and setting unrealistic goals, but to take a pragmatic approach focused on reducing the amount of AI slop. The new approach allows useful code to be accepted even if it is suspected that it was created with the help of AI, as long as certain conditions are met.
For example, it recognizes that for reverse engineering and binary blob analysis, the use of AI is justified if it significantly speeds up the effort to create free alternatives to proprietary code and the process of applying AI is fully controlled by a developer who understands what he is doing. Libreboot is also willing to accept AI-powered changes from trusted professionals who take ownership, understand every line of code, and use AI to accelerate development that would otherwise be impossible for one person to achieve. An example is Arthur Heyman, who used AI to porting Coreboot to the ThinkPad x61.
The creators of Libreboot also recognize that free code written with AI is better than having only proprietary blobs, which are also possibly created through AI. If the code is open and works as intended, then its origin is secondary, and the freedom it provides to users is primary. An example is the ReBIOS